 |
I decided to by the DVD after watching "Into the West". I really liked BMHAWK; it´s telling the story of the continued attemps of the governement to put Indians on reservations and "civilize" them. It is not the black-and-white kind of story. Neither making the white people the really bad guys nor proposing the Natives to be the holy heroes. It paints a picture that seems realistic to me, bringing up many details. I learned a lot of history through it, for example I could grasp the meaning of Cody´s Wildwest-Show better, and how much the Indians were depending on the rations and supply. The actors are fitting the roles greatly, some parts of the movie touched me deaply. I would recommand it to anyone :)
Wounded Knee evokes a great deal of emotion for me, and it was with reluctance that I finally sat down to watch this film. Knowing the details of the massacre, and how women, children and old people were chased down and murdered, was something I wasn't sure I could watch - even in a movie. One reviewer on Amazon gave this a very thorough review, and he noted that while it was fairly accurate historically, it was not completely so. I won't steal his words for this review. After following the steady downward spiral of the Sioux people into nearly complete destruction over a period of 14 years, the end was, well . . . given cursory attention, a gloss over, Hollywood-ized. According to Black Elk (read Black Elk Speaks for a firsthand account), those "wagon guns" went on firing for a long, long time. The scenery was well chosen, the sets fairly realistic, and of course, the (Canadian) Native actors who reenacted their American cousins' history were terrific. What should have been the climax of this endeavor, the Wounded Knee Massacre, was handled pathetically. Such a tragic end to a beautiful way of life deserved far more and better attention than it received. It was the sheer brutality of the soldiers as they shot women and infants at point blank range, their insulting demeanor towards a desperate people, their desire for revenge for Custer's defeat at Little Big Horn, the overwhelming evil that was unleashed that day, that is left out. For that alone, this film falls very, very short of the mark in explaining the grief and mourning, and anger, a people still feel for their lost past. While no fault of the film makers, as a final insult, in the notes at the end of the film, you will see that Congressional Medals of Honor were bestowed upon these "heroes" for their part in this, to use Black Elk's own word, butchery. Dee Brown's classic book upon which this movie is based is far more detailed. As in most cases, the book is better than the movie. If I could change my rating to no star, I would.Vollständige Rezension lesen
I read the book in the mid-seventies. The book impressed me so much and as a young white woman, at the time, it was a life altering experience. I have talked of the book throughout the years. The movie version is powerful and complex, but as always had I not read the book, this movie may have been hard to follow. Anyone that has any questions about events that took place during this era, and the arrogant hand the white man had in Indian affairs and atrosities would be inlightened by this movie. I do however, recommend reading the book first.
After reading the book, I felt that this DVD was a sorry version of what really happened. I know Hollywood can’t put all the sad and horrific details of what truly happen in a two hour movie. But I felt that this movie missed the point of what the story was trying to tell us. It was too watered down and it seemed like the whites ONCE AGAIN are trying to make excuses for themselves for the slandering of innocent Native American/Americans Indians. I know they didn’t want to make the Indians look like the bad guys warriors in the movie but they also didn’t want to take full blame for any of the massacre themselves “We didn’t shoot first”. I personally didn’t like this movie. For now I’ll stick with the books true version of what happened until maybe someday a Native American Indian can make a more close to the full truth version of the movie. That may be the only way we’ll ever get to understand the true account of what really happened. So for me this movie got two thumbs down.Vollständige Rezension lesen
I have always wanted this movie. I have watched it many times on HBO and thought this would be a fine movie to add to my collection. It's a story about what had happened after Custer's revolt on the Little Big Horn..is fault or not, things could have been done differently if Custer would have waited for proper orders. The massacre wouldn't have been so bad and the indians wouldn't have to resort to the reservations. Sitting Bull was killed and their wasn't any food to eat for the indians. Wounded Knee is a actual place and there weren't anymore ghost riders.
Aktuelle Folie {CURRENT_SLIDE} von {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Meistverkauft in DVDs & Blu-rays
Aktuelle Folie {CURRENT_SLIDE} von {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Hier sparen: DVDs & Blu-rays
Aktuelle Folie {CURRENT_SLIDE} von {TOTAL_SLIDES}- Auch interessant
