The formula is great relating to the lightweight and matte finish, but I was very disappointed about the shades. I am a light medium (caramel) toned with golden undertones. I would have thought the 8.75 or 9 would have been perfect but they were both too light. The description says that those shades have the golden undertone, but I did not see that at all. I was also stuck with this because the seller did offer me an exchange or return. Would not recommend for darker shaded people.